Dumbarton 1 - 0 Elgin City 

Scottish Cup - 3rd Round
Saturday, November 18th, 2017, 3:00 PM at YOUR Radio 103FM Stadium
Attendance: 491
Referee: Colin Steven
Dumbarton v Elgin City, Nov 18th 2017, YOUR Radio 103FM Stadium
Dumbarton  Elgin City

Stuart Carswell (24)

Team Managers
Stevie Aitken Gavin Price

Starting Eleven
Scott Gallacher
Sam Wardrop
Dougie Hill
Craig Barr
Andy Dowie
Kyle Hutton
Stuart Carswell
Tom Walsh
Calum Gallagher
Ally Roy
Mark Stewart
Marc Waters
Chris Dodd
Cameron Eadie
Darryl McHardy
Jordan Allan
Jon-Paul McGovern
Stephen Bronsky
Thomas Reilly
Brian Cameron
Alisdair Sutherland
Chris McLeish

Jamie Ewings
David Wilson
Chris Johnston
Kyle Prior
Greg Morrison
Christian Nade
Scott Smith
Calum Ferguson
Jamie Reid
Declan Byrne
Lee Scott
Trevor Dear

Greg Morrison for Calum Gallagher (65)
David Wilson for Ally Roy (75)
Christian Nade for Mark Stewart (88)
Calum Ferguson for Chris Dodd (65)
Jamie Reid for Alisdair Sutherland (80)

Stuart Carswell (60)
Greg Morrison (86)

Red Cards
None. None.
Appearances & Goals To Date
Scott Gallacher (GK) 21 apps -
Sam Wardrop 17 apps1 goal
Dougie Hill 15 apps -
Craig Barr 18 apps2 goals
Andy Dowie 19 apps -
Kyle Hutton 17 apps -
Stuart Carswell 26 apps1 goal
Tom Walsh 34 apps2 goals
Calum Gallagher 24 apps1 goal
Ally Roy 19 apps2 goals
Mark Stewart 18 apps4 goals
David Wilson (sub) 21 apps1 goal
Greg Morrison (sub) 9 apps -
Christian Nade (sub) 44 apps12 goals

Starting Lineup
Youngest Player:Sam Wardrop (20 years 34 days)
Oldest Player:Andy Dowie (34 years 247 days)
Average Player Age:26 years 204 days
Domestic Players:11 (100.00 % of starting eleven)

Matchday Squad
Youngest Player:Kyle Prior (18 years 85 days)
Oldest Player:Andy Dowie (34 years 247 days)
Average Player Age:26 years 23 days
Domestic Players:16 (94.12 % of matchday squad)

First Team Debuts


THE Road to Hampden has started.

And however Dumbarton achieved it, that's the bottom line. They got there.

They scored their first goal in their last five Scottish Cup ties, going back to January 2016. It's a long wait - but not half as long as the one endured by the player who got it.

Stuart Carswell had never scored in over 160 senior games, so he may as well have broken that duck in style.

A 20-yard free kick, in the 24th minute, wasn't a bad way to do it at all.

Luck was ridden for spells after that, with Sons not as fluent as they were in their previous outing against Raith Rovers. Close to the hour mark Brian Cameron hit the post with Elgin's closest chance of the day.

But after results in last season's Scottish Cup, any victory would be welcome, and that job was done.

This was Elgin's first visit to G82 since they were hit for six by Dumbarton's class of 2008/09, a result which gave Sons the Third Division title in all but name.

But although Tom Walsh did go close with an early effort which went just over, the visitors, faring well in League Two this season, were hungry to prove a point.

And only a close range save by Scott Gallacher denied Thomas Reilly after he connected with a low ball from the right.

Then Ally Roy was fouled 20 yards out. Up stepped...a player who had never scored at senior level.

It may have taken a deflection, but Carswell proved the old adage about buying tickets and winning lotteries. Sons were in front and only the hard-hearted would deny him his moment of glory.

Soon after, Roy's bending shot was touched over the bar, while Mark Stewart and Craig Barr each missed the target at close range.

Nine minutes into the second half, Barr could have ended the goal of the tournament competition almost straight away. His run beat four Elgin defenders, but his shot couldn't beat the keeper.

The visitors, though, weren't going away and having frustrated Dumbarton several times in midfield, began forcing chances.

An incisive through ball found Cameron, the only survivor from that 2009 game who took part in this one. His shot beat Gallacher, but bounced out off the inside of the post.

With that escape still registering in some people's minds, Elgin were then awarded a 20-yard free kick which Reilly bent narrowly over.

The rest of the afternoon was frustrating for Sons, but they did finish strongly. After Greg Morrison's strong penalty claim resulted only in a booking for simulation, his fellow sub Christian Nade cut in from the right but couldn't score from a narrow angle.

Walsh also found Carswell in the area with a minute to go, but it was too good to be true and Elgin cleared.

Match report by Andy Galloway

Photography by Donald Fullarton


Programme cover / Team sheet